Laptop auditing website surrounded by office items
  • By Shruchi
  • 25 Oct 2025
  • 19 minute read

Doing a free SEO audit might sound overwhelming, but it’s actually a series of straightforward steps. If you’re trying to figure out why your website isn’t getting much traffic, or you just want to know if you’re missing something obvious, this guide is for you. We’ll walk through the tools you need, what to look for, and how to make sense of the numbers. No fancy words, just real, actionable advice you can use right away.

Essential Tools for a Free SEO Audit

Starting an SEO audit sounds daunting, but with the right free tools, it’s surprisingly doable. Here’s a rundown of what you’ll want in your toolkit, how each fits into the process, and the differences between them.

Using Google Analytics and Google Search Console

If you’re not already set up with Google Analytics (GA) and Google Search Console (GSC), make that your first step. These two tools reveal what’s really happening with your website traffic, page visibility, and search performance.

  • Google Analytics:
  • Google Search Console:

To see where your site’s gains and losses are, always compare both GSC and GA data month-over-month. Don’t panic at every dip—look for steady trends instead.

Leveraging Free Website Crawlers

Website crawlers scan your site much like Google’s bots, finding issues you might miss by hand. A few user-friendly, free options:

  • Screaming Frog SEO Spider (free for up to 500 URLs)
  • Ahrefs Webmaster Tools (free site audit features)
  • Sitebulb Lite (offers basic audits without a paid plan)

These tools help:

  • Find broken links (404s)
  • Flag duplicate meta tags
  • Map your site’s structure for problems
  • Spot missing headers or unoptimized images

Here’s a quick table showing what some popular free crawlers cover:

Tool Scan Limit Highlights
Screaming Frog (Free) 500 URLs Broken links, basic on-page SEO
Ahrefs Webmaster Unlimited Backlink profile, technical audit
Sitebulb Lite Limited Internal linking, site architecture

Utilizing Page Speed and Technical Analysis Tools

Visitors expect websites to be quick. Slow load times can drive them away—and affect your ranking. Instead of guessing, use these free speed and tech analysis tools:

  • Google PageSpeed Insights: Scores both desktop and mobile speed, lists exact fixes (like image compression)
  • GTmetrix: Breaks down load time factors, waterflow charts
  • Schema Markup Validator: Checks if your structured data is working

Focus on the fixes with the biggest impact first, like image size, script minification, and server response time.

Three things you don’t want to ignore:

  1. Mobile loading scores (Google really cares)
  2. HTTPS errors (your site should be secure everywhere)
  3. Technical crawl errors, like robots.txt blocking pages

With these tools, you can start an SEO audit without spending a dime. Each one shows you a different side of your website’s health, so make time to check them all. You’ll be surprised at what they reveal.

Analyzing Organic Traffic Patterns and Performance

Getting a handle on how your organic traffic flows and shifts is just the starting point if you want to figure out what’s working and what’s just burning daylight on your website. Paying attention to these numbers is how you set the stage for steady SEO wins. Let’s look closely at how you can break this down step by step.

Identifying High-Performing Pages

Not every page is a winner, and that’s fine. The first thing I do is check Google Analytics and open up the “Pages” report to see which URLs are getting the most attention from organic searches. Here are a few things I look for:

  • Pages with the highest organic sessions
  • Content that’s racking up the clicks in Google Search Console
  • URLs with a strong average time on page and lower bounce rate

Here’s a quick view of how this info might land in a simple table:

Page URL Organic Sessions Avg. Time on Page Bounce Rate
/blog/tools 3,200 2:50 37%
/about 1,100 1:15 55%
/product/seo 2,900 3:10 34%

A page with lots of visits and a longer stay means the content’s working. If you notice a few pages performing way above the rest, consider focusing on those topics or expanding related articles next. You can find a more in-depth guide to measuring these metrics in this handy overview of SEO performance tracking.

Spotting Traffic Drops and Trends

Even the best sites see traffic wiggle up and down, but obvious drops shouldn’t be ignored. I like to compare month-over-month and year-over-year numbers in Analytics.

  1. Switch your dashboard to a 30-day view, then toggle to last month vs. this month.
  2. Look for sudden dips—could be a Google update, broken page, or lost links.
  3. See if traffic loss is hitting a few pages or the whole site. Sometimes, it’s just one neglected section.

A sudden dip in organic visits often points to a technical issue or a recent change by Google. Fixing drops early helps avoid bigger headaches down the line.

Benchmarking for Improvement

If you don’t keep score, it’s tough to know if your SEO tweaks actually matter. That’s why it’s vital to set a few benchmarks. Here’s what I check:

  • Average monthly organic sessions
  • Number of keywords ranking on page one
  • Clickthrough rate (CTR) for key landing pages
  • Pages with zero organic visits (maybe time to prune)

Make a basic spreadsheet and jot your numbers down every month, so you spot patterns—or problems—quickly. I’d recommend tracking those metrics alongside specific SEO changes, so you know what’s moving the needle.

There you have it. A real SEO audit isn’t just about finding what’s broken; it’s about knowing what’s working, what’s lagging, and setting yourself up for smarter strategy moving forward.

Evaluating Website Structure and On-Page SEO Elements

Laptop auditing website surrounded by office items
When working on an SEO audit, it’s easy to skip over your website’s structure and the on-page stuff—but don’t. How you shape your site and fill in the details can make or break your results in Google.

Checking Meta Titles and Descriptions

Start by looking at your meta titles and descriptions. They don’t only tell Google what your pages are about, they show up in search results and can reel in clicks. If you spot titles that look the same or are missing, it’s a problem. Here’s a quick way to organize your findings:

Page URL Meta Title Meta Description
/about About Us – Widget Co. Learn who we are.
/services Widget Services – Widget Co Our widget solutions.
/contact Get in touch today!
  • Make sure every page gets a unique title and description
  • Meta titles should lead with keywords users actually search
  • Meta descriptions help users decide to click—make them accurate

Even a small fix, like swapping out generic meta text for something specific, can help with visibility.

Optimizing Internal Linking and Site Architecture

Now, look at how you connect your pages. Do your high-traffic pages link to other, less-visited but important pages? Is your menu simple to use? Think about it like a grocery store: items are grouped logically, and it’s not hard to find the bread aisle.

Here’s a three-step checklist:

  1. Review every main category and make sure important pages aren’t more than a couple clicks from the homepage
  2. Add internal links where there’s context—if you mention a service, link to that service page
  3. Check for broken links; fix or remove them fast

Making your site easier to get around helps both visitors and Googlebot.

Assessing Mobile Friendliness and Usability

People are searching on their phones all the time, so your pages have to look good on small screens. Pop open your site on your own mobile and just scroll—if you have to pinch or can’t press a button, there’s work to do.

At a basic level, focus on:

  • Responsive design (does your site adjust to screen size?)
  • Readable text and tap-friendly buttons
  • Quick load times (nobody waits for slow pages anymore)

If you’re not sure, Google Mobile-Friendly Test is an easy way to spot mobile headaches.

Good structure and on-page choices mean users stick around longer—and Google notices. It’s worth the effort every single time.

Uncovering and Fixing Content Issues

Laptop auditing website surrounded by office items
Checking your site for content issues is really about getting honest with yourself—sometimes, your best-performing blog post isn’t that good. Or maybe you’ve got pages that don’t say much, or worse: pages that say the same thing over and over. Let’s walk through where things go wrong and what you can actually do about it.

Finding Thin or Duplicate Content

Thin content is that page you whipped up in ten minutes because someone said you needed a landing page, but it’s just 200 words and a stock photo. Duplicate content pops up when your site says the same thing in a few different places—maybe you’ve got similar service pages, or your CMS generated archives without you realizing it.

  • Export a list of your site’s pages from your favorite audit tool.
  • Sort by word count to spot pages with thin content (under 300 words is a common red flag).
  • Use tools like Copyscape to check for duplicate paragraphs across URLs.
  • Combine similar or overlapping pages, or use 301 redirects.
  • Expand brief pages with unique, helpful information your visitors actually want.
Page URL Word Count Duplicate Status
/services/a 150 Yes (with /services/b)
/about-us 950 No
/contact 120 No

Before you delete anything, always check if that page appears in your Google Analytics or ranks for any keywords; sometimes a thin page brings surprising traffic!

Improving Content Quality and Relevance

Nobody likes reading boring, unfocused pages. Content quality can mean the difference between someone signing up or bouncing right off your site.

  • Review your top traffic pages by checking analytics for high views.
  • Update facts, stats, and examples to keep things fresh.
  • Break up big blocks of text with headings, lists, and bullet points.
  • Add calls-to-action so users know what to do next.

A quick checklist:

  1. Is your content up to date?
  2. Is it clear? Easy to understand?
  3. Does it answer the user’s questions?

Addressing Keyword Optimization Opportunities

A good piece of content will naturally hit on what people are searching for, but sometimes, you have to give it a nudge. Look for:

  • Pages that rank for keywords, but not on page 1.
  • Posts with low impressions but good engagement (maybe they’re missing search terms?).
  • Terms your competitors use, but you somehow missed.

How to fix it:

  • Work keywords naturally into headings and main body text.
  • Add related terms (think synonyms or common phrases).
  • Avoid keyword stuffing—it’s obvious and doesn’t work.

Sometimes it feels a little technical, but honestly, it’s about helping your readers find what they’re looking for. If you fix your thin and duplicate pages, make your content useful, and match what people search for, your site will feel more helpful and rank better, too.

Conducting a Backlink and Off-Page SEO Assessment

A strong off-page SEO foundation helps your site get picked up by more people—and search engines notice that. The backbone of this is a healthy backlink profile, but how do you actually figure out where you stand? Let’s break it all down, step by step.

Auditing Backlink Quality and Toxicity

It’s pretty simple: not all links help your site. In fact, some can actually hurt it. Here’s how you get started:

  • Plug your website into a backlink checker (like Ahrefs, SEMrush, or even the free version of Ubersuggest) to view your full list of referring domains.
  • Check if your links look natural. Are they coming from real websites or sketchy directories? Links from spammy or irrelevant sites signal trouble.
  • Look out for any sudden jumps in backlinks—they might mean unnatural link schemes or penalties.
  • Export your data and organize links into quality groups: relevant, high-authority, suspicious, or toxic.
  • If you spot toxic links, you can try to contact the site owner for removal. Only use the disavow tool in extreme cases (like a manual penalty).

A quick chart can make trends clearer:

Link Type % of Total Links Action Needed
Relevant/Trusted 70% Keep
Suspicious 20% Review Individually
Toxic/Spam 10% Remove or Disavow

Many business owners are shocked by how many low-value sites point to them, but it’s all about slow, steady cleanup. You’ll get your site back on track over a few months—not overnight.

Identifying Link Building Opportunities

Once your toxic links are sorted, think about where new, quality links could come from:

  • Do a backlink gap analysis—see where your top competitors are getting links, and what you’re missing. Sites that link to several rivals are great targets.
  • Develop relationships with industry blogs or news outlets for guest posting—don’t overdo it, but focus on value.
  • Consider outreach for broken link building: find outdated links related to your field, then offer your content as a replacement.
  • Review mentions of your brand online where no actual link exists, and kindly ask those site owners for a link.
  • For step-by-step competitor analysis, this backlink gap breakdown gives a good starting point.

Analyzing Competitor Link Profiles

Behind every top search result, there’s probably a link profile working overtime. Here’s one way you can see how you stack up:

  1. Make a shortlist of your main competitors (the ones ranking where you want to be).
  2. Use any SEO tool or even custom Google searches to view their referring domains.
  3. Sort their links by relevance and domain authority. Pay attention not just to the number of links, but who is linking.
  4. Look for patterns, like industry directories, trade associations, or magazine features your competitors have—but you don’t.
  5. Note any unique campaigns or partnerships they use to boost their link count, and brainstorm ways you might earn similar coverage.

Simple Link Profile Comparison Table

Metric Your Site Competitor A Competitor B
Referring Domains 185 330 270
Authority Score Avg 38 44 41
% Links from Blogs 55% 62% 48%

The point isn’t to copy everything, but to spot patterns you can apply to your own site. Sometimes, it’s those industry-specific sites or long-term content partnerships that really move the needle.

Running a Comprehensive Technical SEO Check

A technical SEO check is where you get your hands dirty and see what’s going on under the hood. This is less about keywords and more about how search engines and users can actually access and experience your site. If there’s a problem here, it doesn’t matter how good your content is—it won’t show up or work well for visitors.

Detecting Crawl Errors and Indexing Issues

If Google can’t read your pages, you’re dead in the water. Here’s how to make sure your important pages aren’t blocked or missing:

  1. Open Google Search Console and check the Coverage report. Look for errors like “Submitted URL not found (404)” or “Submitted URL marked ‘noindex’”.
  2. Try searching site:yourdomain.com in Google. Compare the number of results to your actual page count.
  3. Use website crawlers (like Screaming Frog) to find broken links and un-indexable pages.
Issue Tool Quick Fix
404 Errors Search Console Redirect or restore pages
Noindex Tags Website Crawler Remove from key pages
Missing Sitemaps Search Console Submit a sitemap.xml

Often, you’ll find random old URLs from years ago clogging up your reports—cleaning these out always feels satisfying.

Testing Page Speed and Core Web Vitals

Site speed isn’t just a buzzword, it influences how people use your website. If it’s slow, they bounce. Here’s what you should do:

  • Run your site through Google PageSpeed Insights. Take note of the main issues slowing you down.
  • Focus on images—compress and resize them, they’re usually the main culprit.
  • Check your Core Web Vitals (like Largest Contentful Paint and Cumulative Layout Shift) for every major page type.
  • Remove or delay any scripts you don’t need right away, like certain chat widgets.

You can keep track of page speeds with a table:

Page Mobile Score Desktop Score Actions Needed
Home 55 82 Compress hero images
Product Category 72 89 Reduce JS scripts
Blog Post 66 78 Minimize CSS

Ensuring Proper HTTPS Implementation

Switching to HTTPS isn’t optional anymore—Google treats HTTP sites as less trustworthy. To confirm everything is secure:

  1. Type every form of your URL (http, https, www, non-www) in your browser. Every version should forward to the secure (HTTPS) one.
  2. Check Search Console for any crawl errors related to HTTP URLs.
  3. Update any old internal links or resources still using HTTP.
  • Update rel=canonical tags so they only reference HTTPS pages.
  • Look for mixed content warnings—these slow down your pages and make them feel sketchy to visitors.
  • If you’re not sure, run your pages through an SSL checker tool.

Switching everything to HTTPS gives you peace of mind. No more browser warnings popping up for users—just a smoother, more trustworthy experience.

Technical SEO checks aren’t glamorous, but ignoring them is like ignoring a leaking pipe—it gets worse until you fix it. Work through these steps methodically and keep a notebook of any issues so you don’t lose track. It’ll pay off when your rankings start to climb and those stubborn SEO headaches disappear.

Conclusion

Doing an SEO audit might seem like a lot at first, but it’s really just about breaking things down and checking your site step by step. Start with the basics—look at your traffic, crawl your site, and fix any obvious errors. Use tools like Google Search Console, Analytics, and whatever SEO software you can get your hands on, even if it’s just a free trial. Remember, you don’t have to fix everything overnight. Make a list, tackle the biggest problems first, and keep track of what changes you make. SEO is always changing, so regular audits are a good habit to get into. If you stick with it, you’ll start to see improvements in your rankings and traffic. And hey, if you get stuck, there are plenty of guides and tools out there to help you along the way. Good luck!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an SEO audit, and why should I do one?

An SEO audit is a full checkup of your website to see how well it works for search engines like Google. It helps you find problems and areas to improve, so your site can show up higher in search results and get more visitors.

What are the best free tools for an SEO audit?

Some great free tools are Google Analytics, Google Search Console, and Google’s PageSpeed Insights. You can also try free versions of tools like Screaming Frog or Ubersuggest to check for issues and get helpful reports.

How often should I run an SEO audit on my website?

It’s smart to do a basic SEO audit every few months, or at least twice a year. If you make big changes to your website, you should do an audit right after to catch any new problems.

What should I look for during an SEO audit?

Check your website’s traffic, page speed, and how well your pages are doing. Look for broken links, missing meta tags, slow loading times, and make sure your site works well on phones and tablets. Also, check your content for quality and see if you have any bad or spammy backlinks.

How can I fix duplicate or thin content on my site?

First, find pages with very little information or pages that look almost the same. Combine similar pages, add more helpful content, or remove pages that don’t add value. Make sure each page is unique and useful for your visitors.

Will an SEO audit guarantee better rankings?

Doing an SEO audit helps you spot and fix problems, which can lead to better rankings. But there’s no guarantee, since search engines use many factors to decide rankings. Still, regular audits give you a better chance at improving your site’s performance.

Categories: